# Beyond the Surface: How Janaagraha Is Driving Change in India's Cities

**URL:** <https://grove.rainmatter.org/t/beyond-the-surface-how-janaagraha-is-driving-change-in-indias-cities/5396>\
**Category:** Articles and Blogs\
**Created:** [November 21, 2026, 2:48pm UTC](https://grove.rainmatter.org/t/beyond-the-surface-how-janaagraha-is-driving-change-in-indias-cities/5396 "2026-11-21T14:48:17Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Janaagraha](https://grove.rainmatter.org/user_avatar/grove.rainmatter.org/janaagraha/32/2765_2.png) [@Janaagraha](https://grove.rainmatter.org/u/Janaagraha)\
**Post date:** [November 21, 2026, 2:48pm UTC](https://grove.rainmatter.org/t/beyond-the-surface-how-janaagraha-is-driving-change-in-indias-cities/5396/1 "2026-11-21T14:48:17Z")

</div>

# **Beyond the Symptoms: Janaagraha looks deeper into Bengaluru’s waste management challenge**

A pothole. A pile of garbage. A flooded street. We see these problems every day. But why do they keep coming back, despite years of interventions?

The answer often lies beyond what we see on our streets. It lies in the systems that shape how our cities are planned, managed and governed.

**Through _Beyond the Symptoms_, a new essay series by Janaagraha’s Policy and Insights team, we are bringing these deeper urban challenges into focus.**

The series explores the root causes behind persistent civic issues, examining the planning and design, institutional capacities, resources, transparency, accountability and citizen participation that determine how cities function.

The essay turns the spotlight on Bengaluru’s waste management challenge: **Why does so much waste keep piling up?**

At a recent public consultation by the Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) on solid waste management, the idea of engaging citizen volunteers to improve ward-level cleanliness was discussed.

But can citizen participation alone address a challenge that is rooted in larger urban systems? What are the underlying gaps, who is responsible, and what needs to change?

In this essay, **Vaishnavi Chidambaranathan, Pranay Karmakar and Tanisha Hiremath from Janaagraha’s Policy and Insights team** examine the issues behind Bengaluru’s persistent waste problem.

By looking beyond visible symptoms, the series aims to encourage deeper conversations on urban governance, institutional accountability and the systemic changes needed to make our cities work better.

Because lasting solutions to urban challenges begin with understanding what lies beneath the surface.

**Read the essay:** [Link](https://www.janaagraha.org/publications/insights/beyond-the-symptoms-waste/)

# **Every AQI reading in India belongs to someone. Someone breathing it.**

A child walking to school. A pregnant woman breathing polluted air. A worker spending hours at a construction site or traffic signal. An elderly person living with a respiratory illness.

Behind every air quality reading is a person whose everyday life is affected by the air they breathe.

And India’s numbers tell a concerning story.

In 2025, **29 of the world’s 50 most polluted cities and 66 of the top 100 were in India.** India’s most polluted city ranked first globally, recording PM2.5 levels more than 22 times the World Health Organization’s guideline.

But here’s another important question: **Despite the money being spent on improving air quality, are our cities actually breathing easier?**

Over the last six years, approximately ₹11,319 crore was allocated under the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP), including grants from the 15th Finance Commission. Yet, the challenge of improving air quality remains.

To understand what’s happening beyond the pollution numbers, **Janaagraha’s latest report, _Whose Air Is It Anyway? Financing, Governance, and Pathways to Clean Air_, looks at the connection between public spending, urban governance and cleaner air.**

Here are some of the report’s key findings:

**Are cities meeting their air quality targets?**

Of the 69 cities tracked with usable PM10 data, only 10 met their air quality targets over the six-year period.

**Where is the money going?**

Of the ₹7,594 crore spent by cities on air quality interventions until 2024, around 67% (₹5,098 crore) went towards road dust control.

**Is more spending leading to cleaner air?**

Not necessarily. The report finds no significant link between how much a city spent and how much its air quality improved.

These findings point to a bigger challenge. Improving air quality is not just about allocating funds or implementing individual interventions. It is also about how cities plan, spend, monitor outcomes and hold institutions accountable.

**So, what needs to change?**

This is where Janaagraha’s research brings an important perspective to the conversation. By examining air quality through the lens of public finance and urban governance, the report highlights the need for stronger accountability, better incentives and systems that translate public spending into real improvements in the air people breathe.

**Meet the contributors behind the report:**

The research brings together expertise from Janaagraha’s Policy and Insights and Public Finance Management teams, along with climate and air quality experts:

**Anand Iyer** - Policy and Insights Officer, Janaagraha

**Anikha Ashraf** - Fellow - Public Finance Management, Janaagraha

**Sunil Dahiya** - Founder and Lead Analyst, Envirocatalyst

**Samriddhi** - Consultant, Climate Finance

Their collective work brings evidence, financial analysis and governance perspectives to one of India’s most pressing urban challenges.

**Because clean air is more than a technical target or a budget allocation. It is about the child walking to school, the worker at a traffic signal and every citizen waiting to breathe easier.**

**Explore the report:** [_Whose Air Is It Anyway? Financing, Governance, and Pathways to Clean Air_](https://www.janaagraha.org/resources/whose-air-is-it-anyways-financing-governance-and-pathways-to-clean-air/#)

# **Why does getting the government to listen take so much effort?**

A broken footpath. Irregular drinking water supply. Poor public services. Delayed government responses.

For many citizens, getting even basic civic issues addressed means spending considerable time and effort following up with government offices, seeking answers and demanding action.

**But shouldn’t being heard by the government be a basic part of being a citizen?**

In their article published in _Scroll.in_, **Surendra Surwade,** associate manager strategy and partnerships, Janaagraha and **Santosh Nargund,** senior advisor, **Janaagraha** make a compelling case for more citizen-centric governance one where people don’t have to resort to protests, repeated follow-ups or extraordinary efforts to hold their governments accountable.

The article highlights a fundamental gap in India’s democracy. While citizens elect their representatives every five years, they often have limited opportunities to participate in decisions, track public spending or seek accountability between elections.

So, what needs to change?

Janaagraha’s perspective centres on three essential shifts:

**1. Participation: Give citizens a voice in decision-making.**

Citizens should have meaningful opportunities to shape local priorities, plans and budgets. Institutions such as Gram Sabhas, Area Sabhas and Ward Committees need to become active platforms where people can engage with their governments.

**2. Transparency: Make public spending visible.**

Citizens should be able to understand where public money goes, how it is spent and what outcomes it delivers. Accessible information on budgets, projects and public services is essential to building trust.

**3. Accountability: Make governments answerable.**

Governments must regularly report on their commitments and performance. When projects are delayed or services fall short, citizens deserve explanations and credible plans for corrective action.

**Moving from protest to participation**

Drawing on Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s vision of constitutional democracy, the article makes an important argument: India needs to move beyond a system where citizens must constantly fight to secure basic services and rights.

Instead, we need a governance model that is preventive and proactive — one where governments listen before citizens have to shout, respond before they have to protest, and work with citizens rather than simply deliver services to them.

**At Janaagraha, strengthening the relationship between citizens and governments is central to building better cities and a more responsive democracy.**

Because good governance is not just about governments delivering for citizens. It is about citizens having a meaningful voice in how their governments work.

**Read the full article by Janaagraha’s Surendra Surwade and Santosh Nargund in Scroll.in:** [Link](https://scroll.in/article/1096409/why-india-needs-citizen-centric-governance-for-everyday-democracy)
